The other girl is an attractive bookwormish type. She's not shy though. She's really easy to talk to. I find myself getting excited just by having a conversation with her. She's only dated a few guys before, and has never done anything more than just make out with them.
Definitely the second one if you get excited by just carrying a conversation with her it's def. the one
and you said the first one you have heard stories that she is loos so i wouldn't go for her (no homo)